In Indiana and Beyond, Bruising G.O.P. Primary Fights Worry Party Leaders

Winning in all three of these states has taken on added urgency after the unanticipated retirements of Republican senators in Tennessee, Arizona and Mississippi left open seats that could suddenly be competitive.

In Indiana, Representative Todd Rokita started airing a television ad this week that labeled one of his opponents, Representative Luke Messer, a “Never Trump lobbyist” and the other, Mike Braun, a business executive, as voting for either Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama. His slogan: “Defeat the Elite.”

Not Conservatives Video by Rokita for U.S. Senate

“It’s a legitimate three-way race,” said John Hammond, a lawyer and member of the Republican National Committee from Indiana, “and everybody will probably go right up to the line with rhetoric and negative message. It’s happening and it’s intensifying.”


Can Democrats Win the Senate?

Republicans need to win nine senate races to keep a majority, and Democrats need to win 28 to take it away. Here’s a look at the chances of each outcome.

OPEN Graphic

He added, “All the opposition research will have been done for Joe Donnelly at that point.”

Mr. Rokita said he had no concerns that the attacks would help the incumbent Democrat. “I think this primary is very cleansing,” he said. “I want voters to know about these two guys. And I want them to know about me.”

Referring to two previous Republican presidential candidates, John R. Kasich and Mitt Romney, Mr. Rokita added: “Messer at this point is like all losing candidates, like Kasich or Romney, ‘if you beat up on me, we are all going to lose.’ Absolutely wrong. I am not waiting for Joe Donnelly to stick a knife in Luke Messer or Mike Braun in November. I am getting it all out now. Because Donnelly will stick in a knife in them.”

That kind of language has prompted concern among some of the state’s most influential Republicans.

Mr. Grand, who supports Mr. Messer, was particularly critical of Mr. Rokita trying to claim a populist mantle by deriding so-called elites. Mr. Rokita’s “elites” are something else to Mr. Grand: “People that know what’s good for the Republican Party, yes, longstanding Republicans, yes. People who know how to elect Republican candidates.”

“Or,” he asked, does Mr. Rokita “want to go back to the group that gave us Mourdock?”

That was a reference to Richard E. Mourdock, a candidate whose backing from Tea Party groups and national conservative organizations six years ago led to the defeat of a longtime incumbent Republican, Senator Richard G. Lugar, in the Indiana primary. Mr. Mourdock went on to lose to Mr. Donnelly.

Mr. Mourdock painted Mr. Lugar as out of touch with the state, and emphasized the fact that he lived in Virginia, a theme that Mr. Rokita has reprised against Mr. Messer. He has also made an issue of the fact that Mr. Messer’s wife, a lawyer, is on the payroll of an Indianapolis suburb even though she, too, lives in Virginia.

Mr. Messer, the father of two teenage daughters, said he was raised by a single parent and felt it important to be closer to his children, and said voters would understand.

A competitive primary or multicandidate field can sometimes actually reflect party strength and enthusiasm, but if the contest becomes too negative, the party can suffer.


Senator Joe Donnelly of Indiana is one of the most vulnerable Democrats in this year’s midterm elections.

Erin Schaff for The New York Times

“Where there are particularly competitive or divisive primaries, it is bad for the parties when they go to the general,” said Andrew B. Hall, a political scientist at Stanford University who has studied the subject. “Things are getting put on record that make you look weak. You alienate some of your own base. You’ve expended some of your resources.”

Mr. Donnelly has no serious opposition for the Democratic nomination, though he is already under assault from Republican-aligned groups that are spending millions of dollars to defeat him.

Each of the Republican candidates has tried to emphasize ties to Mr. Trump in a state the president won by 19 percentage points. Mr. Braun claims a Trump-like background, having built a logistics company in southern Indiana that now employs 850 people and gave him wealth that he can spend heavily on his own campaign.

He said Mr. Messer and Mr. Rokita were professional politicians, lawyers who “never practiced” but always had their eyes on the next political rung. Mr. Braun served briefly in the State Legislature.

In a candidate debate, in which Mr. Braun wore jeans and a denim shirt, he made the case harshly. In a new ad, he uses humor, carrying cardboard cutouts of the two men — dressed identically in white shirt, red tie and dark suit — and asked voters if they could tell the difference between them.

What’s the difference? Video by Mike Braun for Indiana

“Where is your real world experience?” Mr. Braun said in an interview. “They don’t have any.” He added: “They are creating a large avenue up the middle between two career politicians. That was a gift that kept on giving.”

Mr. Braun dismissed Mr. Rokita as a “smash mouth.”

“He’ll do and say things that might impress,” he said. “If he’s trying to act like Trump it’s kind of a poor impression.”

He also said there could be lingering damage: “When you’ve got sharp elbows, that creates a long memory for the people hit by those elbows.”

2018 Election Calendar and Results

A full list of elections for the House and Senate, including which races matter most for congressional control.

He rejected Mr. Rokita’s charge that he was a recent Republican convert, saying he had never voted for a Democrat for a federal office.

Mr. Messer, whose campaign so far has been the most measured of the three, accused Mr. Rokita of “trying to make things up.”

“It’s crazy,” Mr. Messer said. “You can’t find one interview in the entire campaign where I didn’t make the point that we need to elect President Trump. Do I agree with every single President Trump tweet? No. I’ve expressed a few times my concerns about the president. But throughout, I have supported him and voted for the president in the primary.”

All the candidates embrace some of the president’s core positions, like the need for a wall along the Mexican border, and all pledge to be a solid voice for the president’s agenda.

Mr. Rokita’s opponents say his voting record suggests otherwise: Mr. Rokita voted against the budget deal that Mr. Trump signed this year

He said he did so because the bill contained too much federal spending. But, Mr. Rokita added, because he supported Mr. Trump before his rivals and has the endorsement of people who ran the Trump campaign in the state, he can disagree with the president, something he said Mr. Messer could not do.

“Now he has to do everything he can to pander to the president and Mike Pence,” Mr. Rokita said. “Oh, the president wanted this terrible spending bill. Whereas I, in a very healthy way, can say no to things like the spending bill and still be on the side of the president.”

Even with all the friction in the primary so far, if there are safe places for the midterm elections to be a referendum on Mr. Trump, Indiana is surely among them. Republicans will pour extraordinary resources into the effort to oust Mr. Donnelly, and the president and Vice President Mike Pence, the former Indiana governor, will be able to give the senate nominee added firepower.

That gives Republicans comfort that they can endure a fractious primary. “People are very energized,” Mr. Grand said. “They are not playing into this thing that ’18 is going to be a bad year.”

Continue reading the main story

A New Film Studio From the Moguls Behind Justin Bieber and Marvel

But intellectual property aside, the new business is most likely to draw industry interest for its Avengers-like joining of executive forces.

While Mr. Braun has a reputation as a generational talent-spotter and social-media marketer, Mr. Maisel, 55, was an early architect of Marvel’s world-dominating plan to stop licensing its characters to Hollywood studios and instead self-finance its own movies, beginning with “Iron Man” in 2008. After the company was sold to Disney for $4 billion the following year, Mr. Maisel left; he went on to develop and produce “The Angry Birds Movie,” which, while scoffed at by critics, made $350 million worldwide. That project also got Mr. Maisel thinking about combining comics and all-ages animation for the big screen.

A Harvard M.B.A. who came up as a Hollywood dealmaker under the Creative Artists Agency co-founder Michael Ovitz, Mr. Maisel is also a comic-book obsessive who wore a “Fathom” T-shirt to the interview and brought along a collection of hero figurines.

“I never understood what he was doing, but I always knew he was really, really smart,” Kevin Huvane, the power agent and managing partner at C.A.A., said of Mr. Maisel. “He has this encyclopedic knowledge of comic books and treats them like real art, with a savant-like ability to take out characters that appeal to him and make them really relevant.”


At Mythos Studios, projects in development include an adaptation of the comic book “Fathom.”

Aspen Comics

Together with Mr. Braun, “a connector with access and knowledge of pop culture in all mediums,” Mr. Huvane said, the two make an “explosive combo.”

The Mythos founders met over dinner about five years ago — they had a mutual friend in Kanye West, they discovered — and remained in touch as Mr. Braun’s SB Projects expanded its non-music division under the chief operating officer Scott Manson. As Mr. Maisel circled the Aspen Comics titles, Mr. Braun jumped at the chance to partner with someone whose “main interest is doing the work,” he said. “You don’t see David in all the social circles or at all the parties, but what you do see is a name associated with some of the most amazing properties out there.”

Mr. Manson, who as a longtime friend of Mr. Braun’s refers to his role as “managing the manager,” will serve as a bridge between the Mythos founders. “Scooter’s not going to sit in a boardroom for eight hours,” Mr. Manson said. “That’s why we love David and why we’re partners.”

As part of the deal, Mr. Braun agreed to fund Mythos’s development costs for multiple years through his holding company, Ithaca, while the venture considers moving forward independently, partnering with an existing studio or working with a digital player like Netflix or Amazon. (They won’t disclose a budget.)

Mr. Braun will also provide a potential pipeline for talent (and soundtracks), with the obvious question being: Will Mr. Bieber end up a superhero?

Mr. Braun laughed. “There will be synergies,” he said. “If any of the talent we work with wants to be a part of the projects we’re doing, we welcome them to join us on this journey. I’ve already had conversations with certain talent that are very excited about being a part of this.”

The other question many will have is whether Mythos can break through a glut of comic-book movies with a collection of largely unknown characters. (“Fathom,” about a marine biologist and Olympic swimmer who turns out to be part of an underwater race of humanoids, was once teased as a movie starring Megan Fox, but never happened.)

“Are they as popular as Superman or Batman? No,” Mr. Braun said. “But why do people know the name Forrest Gump? If you tell a great story, people will care.”

Mr. Maisel acknowledged that it’s “a crowded environment out there,” but he recalled being scoffed at for attempting to revitalize Marvel with so-called “D-list characters.”

“It’s hard to think of it now, but at the time even Iron Man people thought of as a triathlon sporting event,” he said. “What I’ve enjoyed doing in my career is to see opportunities that aren’t obvious.”

Mr. Braun added: “We both come from a background of being second-guessed our entire career. I was second-guessed on Ariana Grande, ‘Gangnam Style,’ ‘Call Me Maybe,’ ” he said, ticking off hits. “That’s usually the direction we ran in.”

Continue reading the main story